I make a point to switch off my mobile device upon entering a movie theater. Not simply on do not disturb – completely off. I share this not because I'm superior, or to suggest that the specter of Billy Wilder will materialize to shake my hand. I see it as a genuine minor indulgences: for no less than ninety minutes, I am entirely unreachable. I maintain my phone off for the duration of the scroll as well. It seems indulgent to remain seated as the audience slowly filter out, illuminated solely by the closing titles.
And, lately, by the glow of the cataloguing app.
More than 26 million users use Letterboxd, a film-cataloguing platform. Like the Criterion Collection, it has evolved into industry shorthand for a particular kind of aficionado who hypes new releases and delights in unearthing cinematic treasures. Patrons score and write about films, and the wittiest or most profound critiques ascend to the top, motivating film lovers to craft thoughtful responses.
"If I don't jot down my ideas quickly when the film concludes, my reviews are far less coherent and articulate," said Josh Stern.
During a trip to the movies, the end titles had just begun before the man in the row ahead began typing his thoughts. Not far away, a duo lingered, looking down, jotting down their personal reactions.
The late film-maker David Lynch shared some advice: write down every great idea the exact moment it strikes you. Otherwise, it could vanish, and, as he put it: "Forgetting a valuable thought, you feel like you could commit suicide." Lynch was addressing hopeful creators, a similar ethos applies to the act of reviewing.
A student, a young university attendee in New York, invariably composes his reviews before leaving the auditorium.
"If I don't get my thoughts out immediately once the movie ends, my write-ups are much less clear and eloquent," he stated. "It takes a bit. I take my time, and my significant other gets impatient."
He goes to the movies often – 182 times the previous year – and is on a friendly footing with the theater staff, who sometimes must usher him out so they can commence sweeping the rows. He believes it acceptable to utilize the credit sequence: "Upon buying a cinema ticket, the end titles are part of the movie."
The platform's most ardent users attribute the platform with reinvigorating interest around a challenged film industry, where fewer films are made and joblessness is high. (Letterboxd also has the kind of demographics brands seek – its largest cohort of users is aged 18 and 24, followed by 25 to 35.)
Hype generates more hype; highly awaited movies witness a rash of reviews on Letterboxd right after the premiere showtimes. The highest-rated comment of an acclaimed adaptation – "Emily Brontë passed away long ago yet this version is still the greatest injustice that has ever happened to her" – has received more than 50,000 hearts. A separate fictionalized retelling produced this juxtaposition to a pop star's documentary: "that other tour film left in the dust."
"It's somewhat a compulsion," commented a marketing professional, a 33-year-old New Yorker who is employed in marketing. He also chooses to compose critiques during the end sequence. "Reflecting on what you just experienced, as soon as you experienced it, enhances the cinematic journey. It aids in understanding the central themes of a film. If it produces a sensation of a warm hug, that's not always something you recall the next day."
He feels most compelled to critique a film if it was very good – or awful. As an illustration: he recently endured a big-budget project. "I found myself so offended by how egregiously bad it was, that I was eager to whip out my phone and award it a one-half star score," he said. (He is a tougher reviewer than established professional critics, who assigned the film three stars, describing it as "smart and entertaining fare.")
Dakota Chester, a twenty-eight-year-old professional who manages social media, saw a fantasy animated film at a cinema on the Upper West Side and remained to write the write-up ("it got five stars"). He has witnessed more egregious conduct: people whipping out their phones to Letterboxd the movie they are currently watching. "That annoys me," he commented.
One of film's longest-running tales recounts a showing of a pioneering silent short that showed a train arriving at a station. The medium was in its formative period and – according to this largely discredited rumor – the shot of a locomotive heading straight toward the camera frightened the spectators so much that people scattered screaming.
A hundred and thirty years later, cinema etiquette is just as poor. Often, few people remember how to conduct themselves any more, particularly when the theater darkens: patrons take pictures of the screen, smuggle in smelly food, and, as was reported during a blockbuster summer, occasionally engage in fights.
Certain people have taken to social media to discuss the propriety of writing reviews throughout the end sequence. When one social media user